Internal Emails From Nursing Director At Brigham And Women’s Hospital Show Doctor Is Lying About Capacity, Says Only 20% Of ICU Beds Are COVID Patients
This is Abraar Karan, a doctor at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School.
Karan was featured in a Boston.com story yesterday after a tweet of his got a lot of attention, claiming that there are no ICU beds left at his hospital, and urging restaurants to be shut down because he baselessly insinuates that correlation is causation.
1/ Been saying this for a while, but I’m going to say it again. Do not indoor dine right now. Order takeout. Tip restaurants. Support businesses. But I would not be dining indoors. Last night, there were no ICU beds left at a hospital where I work in Boston. #COVID19
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) December 8, 2020
“Last night, there were no ICU beds left at a hospital where I work in Boston.”
Posted by Boston.com on Wednesday, December 9, 2020
He also stated in the thread that shutting down the economy has nothing to do with the economy, and it’s just a lie being spread by rich people because “wealthy powerful people are the last people that are going to be doing the high risk activities they say are safe for everyone else.”
Wealthy people like California Governor Gavin Newsom, who likes to eat at indoor restaurants with over a dozen people without masks on, and then tells you that you must close your business because it’s your fault the virus is spreading.
Gavin Newsome’s French Laundry (inside) soirée – no masks. “Do as I say, not as I do. Oh, and Happy Thanksgiving!!”- Marie Antoinette pic.twitter.com/jOqLMFjRgd
— Honor Rubbly (@jdaddy007) November 19, 2020
Our ICUs are climbing quickly toward their capacity. Our death rate is rising.
To slow the surge of #COVID19 and save lives, CA is introducing a Regional Stay-At-Home Order.
Regions where ICU capacity⁰fall below 15% will be placed into this Stay-at-Home Order ⁰for 3 weeks.
— Gavin Newsom (@GavinNewsom) December 3, 2020
Fear porn like this is designed to frighten people from living their lives and pressure the government to close down restaurants because we’re being told that restaurants and businesses are the reason that there is no room left in the ICU.
However, TB Daily News has been alerted by a whistle blower who works at Brigham and Women’s that this is a lie. Here’s an email sent out Tuesday by BWH nursing director Barbara Clemons, letting nurses know that only 20% of ICU beds are occupied by COVID patients, that patients are recovering quicker and better from COVID thanks to new therapies, and that they have an ample supply of PPE.
To be clear, Dr. Abraar Karan works at this same hospital and is claiming that the ICU beds are completely filled with COVID patients, and it’s because of indoor dining.
This man is just lying to the public because he can. He sits on the Epidemic Response team for the Mass Department of Public Health, is a frequent contributor to NPR, and a “reviewer” for the CDC.
Needless to say he has profited immensely from COVID, and the longer this goes on the longer he can continue to do so. It’s in his best interest to make the public believe that the virus is worse than it is.
In reality the hospitals are busier during the winter due to seasonal flu and other diseases spreading. His job, like any job, would be much easier if he were less busy. Therefore he wants you to stop living your life, and for restaurants to be forced to close down, knowing full well that he will continue to receive a doctor’s salary.
Now let’s see what Abraar Karan had to say about protests in June.
- He spoke out in support of “anti-racism protests” with over 50,000 people jammed closely together because “COVID 19 is being driven by racism”
When we spoke out in support of anti-racism protests, we were criticized as playing to politics.
Well- the data is here.
The American #covid19 is being driven by racism. The good thing about arguing w/ data is that it doesn't care what your opinion is.https://t.co/InxbeqkSo9
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) July 7, 2020
- Said that we couldn’t stop the spread of the virus until racism stopped existing, which will never happen and is a completely made up lie coming from a “public health expert.”
THREAD
There is no stopping #covid19 without stopping racism.As doctors, we openly denounce #racism; we call for it to be treated as the public health emergency that it is; we urge our colleagues to do the same. To be silent is to do harm.@bmj_latest https://t.co/Ikuc0HNskB pic.twitter.com/nXoNwea7rc
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) June 5, 2020
- Doctors shouldn’t bother telling protesters to stop because they won’t listen, and the only solution was to “address what the protests are about,” which ultimately means “abolish the police and then we’ll stop protesting.”
If you want protests to stop, maybe try addressing what the protests are about.
If you want “public health” to “tell protestors to stop”, that won’t work.
Tone-deaf, reductive paternalism rarely does.
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) June 7, 2020
- He said that black people should be protesting because “How can you tell somebody not to protest for their life?” As if they will die if they do not protest, simply because a rogue cop in Minnesota killed a black man.
Spoke about #covid19, protests, and taking a stance against #racism, which is a public health crisis.
cc @MTVNEWS @Dometi_ pic.twitter.com/mrCMtKUB5E
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) June 7, 2020
- If you’re concerned about 50,000 person protests jamming up the streets of Boston during a pandemic, then you are likely a hypocrite because you wanted businesses to open back up a week before. In reality people were furious at hypocrite doctors like this who advocated for lockdowns and then cheered on protests.
1/ Some more thoughts about #covid19 and the #BlackLivesMatter protests…
If the sole concern against protests were about *viral transmission*, the same concerned people should have been even more upset about reopening early weeks ago as they are about outdoor protests today.
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) June 12, 2020
- Protests magically don’t cause the virus to spread, while ignoring the fact that they happened in June, not November.
There are many reasons why we have yet to see any sizeable “spikes” of #covid19 cases after #BlackLivesMatter protests. @germanrlopez covers it in this solid @voxdotcom piece:https://t.co/AeMIpF8Ko4
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) June 26, 2020
- Said that huge protests helped increase testing which stopped the spread of COVID
For those wondering what effects the protests against #racism have had in the immediate term, watch this.
Neglected areas of #Boston that didn’t have #covid19 testing now do.
What “couldn’t be done” in *months* happened in *days*
Cc @wbz https://t.co/fzrm9zkvxe pic.twitter.com/WBn2WX7KTc
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) June 10, 2020
- Said that it’s OK to protest “for your life” (BLM), but not OK to protest to open up businesses like barber shops so that business owners can make a living
3/ Those who are oddly but noticeably quiet right now— afraid of being seen as “political”; afraid of being reprimanded by critics who equate protesting for life with protesting for a haircut—your silence is deafening. If you won’t put skin in the game now, then when?
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) June 5, 2020
- Said that it was outrageous that police teargassed a nursing assistant, but said nothing about the fact that this healthcare worker was in a mob of violent people, spreading disease with her mask pulled down, and likely went to work the next day.
Police attacked a nursing assistant and patient who was bleeding from rubber bullet wounds.
Outrageous.#BlackLivesMatter #protests2020 pic.twitter.com/2YXKGptOl8
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) May 31, 2020
- Encouraged protesting without masks on by sharing a video of two black men shouting at each other without social distancing, and without masks on, during a protest
Let this *break your heart* & then let it push you to fight as hard as you can so that we no longer live in a country that systematically oppresses and kills black Americans. #BlackLivesMatter #protests2020 pic.twitter.com/gqcm2uImnI
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) June 1, 2020
- Justified large protests by falsely and arbitrarily claiming that racism is a “public health emergency”
And to the shock of absolutely nobody he’s also not a fan of Donald Trump.
How about no kneeling on a man’s neck for 8 minutes and 46 seconds?#GeorgeFloyd #BlackLivesMatter https://t.co/dLqyeNrs4S
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) June 5, 2020
Meanwhile we are recording some of the deadliest days in American history every week and our President has yet to acknowledge it. #covid19 https://t.co/3IBKdYeNwu
— Abraar Karan (@AbraarKaran) December 9, 2020
Stop listening to “public health experts,” who lie, fear monger, tell you that viruses don’t spread at protests, and clearly are driven by a political agenda. The hospitals were never over capacity during the first surge and they’re not over capacity now either.
Stand up, fight back, be free.
Hello Turtle Riders. As you know if you follow Turtleboy we are constantly getting censored and banned by Facebook for what are clearly not violations of their terms of service. Twitter has done the same, and trolls mass reported our blog to Google AdSense thousands of times, leading to demonitization. We can get by and survive, but we could really use your help. Please consider donating by hitting the PayPal button above if you’d like support free speech and what we do in the face of Silicon Valley censorship. Or just buy our award winning book about the dangers of censorship and rise of Turtleboy: