TB Investigates

Canton Cover-Up Part 229: Two Months After Letting John O’Keefe Die In Cold Jennifer McCabe Started “Peggie’s Angels,” Took John O’Keefe’s Mom And Niece Out To Dinner With “Real Housewives Of Canton” 


Donate to the Turtleboy Legal defense fund

– Framed – Video for Full Background on Canton Cover-Up Story
– Donate to the Karen Read Legal Defense Fund
– See all parts of the Canton Cover-Up Series
– Watch the Live Shows and Videos
– Join ”Justice for John O’Keefe and Karen Read” FB Group

Multiple sources from Canton sent messages today telling us that Jennifer McCabe’s Jeep was parked at the free house Peggie O’Keefe inherited from her murdered son, just hours after we published the damning 911 tape showing that McCabe did nothing to save John O’Keefe’s life after finding him alive in the snow.

Manipulating the O’Keefe’s is essential for the conspirators who murdered him and framed Karen Read because they believe it gives them moral superiority to have the backing of John’s remaining family. It’s why they often deflect from their own guilt and hide behind the O’Keefes – they are useful human shields.

When I first announced on April 17 that I was writing about this case, and I made it clear that I would be taking a pro-defense position due to the facts and evidence in their favor, I received several message from supporters of the McAlberts who tried to prevent me from writing the story. These people already followed me, were clearly fans of Turtleboy, and understood the influence the article would have on public opinion. And since these people knew that the facts and evidence were against them they all used the O’Keefe family as a weapon to try to prevent me from exposing their friends.

Karl Dugal was clearly skeptical of the McAlberts when he messaged me in April, stating that he “would like to know the truth,” about “whoever left him to die on a front lawn in a snowstorm.” He conceded that I “may be right” about who was responsible, because even someone as stubborn as Karl cannot be completely blind to the facts. But he, like all of the McAlbert supporters, used John’s niece and nephew as pawns in order to protect the people who killed John.

Why would anyone who cares about justice object to autopsy photos being shown if they could shed light on how John was murdered, and who murdered him?

None of these people could articulate why the defense was actually wrong. None of them could explain or justify the 2:27 Google search, the Apple Health data, Ryan Nagel’s testimony, the dog scratches, or the failure of Michael Proctor to reveal obvious conflicts with witnesses. They all agreed that the defense had created reasonable doubt for Karen simply by citing evidence, and claimed that the prosecution couldn’t combat that with their own facts “without compromising the case.” They all promised big bombshells to come, which have never arrived.

That is why their only play is to use Peggy O’Keefe, Paul O’Keefe, and John’s two innocent, twice orphaned children, as human pawns in their online game of murder coverup. The bad guys aren’t the ones sharing the autopsy photos or defending Karen Read. The bad guys are the people who use the O’Keefes as a weapon to prevent you from talking about any of this.

The McAlberts have been trying to push the narrative hard that I have attacked the O’Keefe family and booed them at the courthouse. They use disgraced former FBI diversity hire Jennifer Coffindaffer as their mouthpiece to spread these lies, which are easily debunked by video footage explicitly asking people NOT to boo the O’Keefes on the courthouse stairs.

In the Boston Magazine article about the Karen Read case Gretchen Voss made sure to include this lie, by including out of context quotes in which I am critical of Paul O’Keefe for drunk driving and aligning with his brother’s killers. They push this narrative hard because if people aren’t talking about how mean I am to the O’Keefes then they might focus on all of the facts and evidence proving the McAlbert’s guilt.

People like Karl Dugal and Paul O’Keefe are blinded by hatred for Karen Read, and their behavior is less forgivable and less understandable than Jennifer McCabe’s behavior. At least Jen and her co-conspirators were in self-preservation mode, trying to save themselves from potential life in prison. Karl and Paul have committed no crimes (recently), and claim to love John. Yet they’ve aligned themselves with the people who even they concede MAY have been involved in murdering their friend and brother.

Jennifer McCabe is one of the most cold hearted criminals I’ve ever seen, and definitely someone you would want on your team if you ever murdered someone. She quarterbacked the entire operation, immediately going into self-preservation mode after realizing that John was dying inside 34 Fairview Road and would likely not survive.

Jennifer McCabe commissioned her daughter Allie to take part in a murder coverup by acting as the getaway driver for Colin Albert. Keep in mind, Allie was 17 years old and out driving past midnight during a blizzard. My mother wouldn’t let me drive in the rain because she thought I would hydroplane. She didn’t let me drive minors to and from parties where they were consuming alcohol at 1 in the morning during a nor’easter.

What kind of mother would have her teen daughter drive Colin home when she could do have driven Colin home herself? But then she wouldn’t have been able to sit in the house, plot the coverup, and make sure the loose ends of Julie Nagel and Sarah Levinson knew what to say if asked.

There is a reason that Jen and Chris are the two most active McAlberts in this story – their children both took part in a murder and/or the subsequent coverup. They are fighting like only a parent can.

When Jennifer called 911 she showed zero emotions, and referred to her good friend John O’Keefe as simply a “man lying in the snow.” She didn’t go inside her sister’s unlocked house to get blankets, even after the dispatcher told her to find blankets.

She made sure to speak with all 5 responding Canton Police Officers while Karen Read was screaming and trying to save John O’Keefe’s life. While Karen was sent to the hospital for mental health treatment because she was experiencing genuine trauma, Jen was emotionless and able to speak with Sgt. Michael Lank on the phone at 8:38 and 8:59, before calling Michael Proctor’s personal cell phone and planting the LIE that Karen Read admitted to running John over with her car.

But Jen knew that the most important person she needed on her side wasn’t Proctor, Lank, or Michael Morrissey – it was Peggie O’Keefe, and by extension Paul O’Keefe and John’s niece and nephew. That’s why she called Peggy at 1:38 PM and had a 7 minute conversation after she knew Karen had left 1 Meadows Ave for the last time with her parents.

It’s why she started making cheap “Justice for JJ” pins and wearing them to court.

It’s why she rubbed the shoulders of other attention seeking drama queens in court who believed her lie that Karen killed John.

It’s why she got John’s niece to transfer out of Bishop Feehan and go to Canton High School as a sophomore so she could be closely integrated with and monitored by the McAlberts.

It’s why she brought John’s niece to school orientation night.

It’s why she left heart emojis on Peggie O’Keefe’s Facebook page every time she shared a picture of John.

And it’s why on April 13, 2022, Jennifer McCabe did something that will make your stomach spin – went out to dinner with John’s niece and Peggie and inducted her into the “Real Housewives of Canton” as part of the group they call “Peggie’s Angels.” Jen made sure to sit directly across the table with the child she helped turn into an orphan for the second time.

I shared this image on Twitter today, and the response from the few remaining McAlbert defenders, all of whom hide behind anonymity, was predictably, “How dare you share a picture of John’s niece that was publicly used for McAlbert propaganda on Facebook!”

These people simply don’t exist in real life, just on Twitter. My response to their faux outrage is this – stop pretending like any of you frauds care at all about John O’Keefe or his family. I get it – this is all you have. Without the ability to use them as human shields you’d have to publicly defend some of the most vile, unlikeable people in Turtleboy history.

But just know that your words are meaningless, and although you maybe have been able to fool Gretchen Voss, Jennifer Coffindaffer, and other easily duped individuals, you haven’t fooled millions of people, and you certainly haven’t fooled the FBI. Your day is coming, and all you’re doing is ensuring that when that day comes it will be the most glorious victory in the decade long history of Turtleboy.


Hello Turtle Riders. As you know if you follow Turtleboy we are constantly getting censored and banned by Facebook for what are clearly not violations of their terms of service. Twitter has done the same, and trolls mass reported our blog to Google AdSense thousands of times, leading to demonetization. We can get by and survive, but we could really use your help. Please consider donating by hitting the Donation button above if you'd like support free speech and what we do in the face of Silicon Valley censorship. Or just buy our award winning book about the dangers of censorship and rise of Turtleboy:  Qries


  1. $10k in facial creams and makeup at that table didn’t do a bit of good. Scary Skeletor Jen McToothy leaning in from the back with a face only Maria Shriver could love.

    Every husband or bf of that group of harpies get’s pegged and whipped.

  2. Jen McCabe, You are an EVIL woman… You participated in killing a man that you claim was your friend. You had hours to change the course of your decision and do the humane thing but you didn’t. You are GUILTY of 1st Degree MURDER.

    As for John’s family. They have been groomed and manipulated since his death by Jen McCabe and others. She’s had to work extra hard at making sure his family trusted her and believed in her.

    When they do come to the realization of what her motives were they will be devastated.

    I will never understand how a mother could be so EVIL and SINISTER. Jail is where you belong.

  3. John’s poor niece, you can see the sadness in her eyes, the smile doesn’t disguise it, she looks like she feels out of place as well. My heart breaks for those kids.

    1. So sad….J M has John’s neice and nephew going to public schools in f Cau**own…..wth…..I feel so horrible for those children not just because they are making then go to school there. But the fact they lost everyone who truly loved them. And yellow button has custody? Clearly by the pictures and tb pics they are imo extremely uncomfortable with everything. JO stepped up when no one else would and managed a full time job as a B po💙 KR obviously helped in so many ways. It’s just unbelievable that people hate her and they hate her because imo how dare she come to our town!! I didn’t listen to the 911 call it’s going to make me sad…mad…etc. But that’s just me.knowing it exists is enough… Justice for John O’Keefe 💙❤️KR
      Those children,god bless their hearts💖 I hope when they are old enough the be able to understand what really happened💝

  4. So the phone call was damning enough to make Jen McCabe personally visit the o’keefes and explain herself? Well done.

  5. One thing that always stuck with me/bothered me.
    John fought his mother for custody over his sister’s kids and he won.
    That is an unusual win in the court system.
    He was not married, worked full time, and was not a parent himself.
    What exactly made the court rule in his favor?
    How receptive to this were the family?
    Was there some bad blood or all good?
    Also, I hate to say this but $ can do some strange things to people.
    Karen Read opened a trust for the kids.
    Was she able to control it in some way?
    If she goes to prison does that go to the guardian?
    There was a go fund me that the brother is in charge of. That go fund me raised a lot of money.
    Is there an un objective party that over sees this? Makes sure it goes to the children?
    The loss is evident. That can’t be easy.
    I can’t imagine the loss for that family.
    Not making accusations, just curious.

    1. I would think that there is a conservator involved…remembering back to the Aaron Hernandez case, Avielle was the daughter. Well, anyway you may remember Aaron’s fiancé (Shayanna Jenkins) was blowing money left and right. The conservator took her to court on behalf of the child to stop her from continuing.

    2. You have a great point about John fighting his mother in court for his nieces and nephews. What was behind that? I can’t imagine that she was pleased with that move?

  6. New level of disgust for Jen McCabe and all the McAlberts. John’s niece and nephew deserve so much better than these monsters. How freaking traumatized are they going to be when the federal government verifies the truth around the murder of their beloved uncle. Absolutely heartbreaking. JM is an actual monster.

  7. This does happen that alleged killers befriend victims families. Totally not normal or healthy, but happens.

    In 1991 Daniel Rees in Ohio killed Rachel Johnson who lived across the street from her. He befriended the victims family for next 30 years before they found out and he was arrested in 2020.

    Rees took Rachel’s daughter who was 2 at time of her moms death on a motorcycle ride, went over to the house for bonfires, even went to family wedding.

  8. Woof. Why does everyone in Canton look way older than they are. Ladies – 📢 PSA 👏🏻 skincare👏🏻 health 👏🏻wellness👏🏻 please.
    Off topic – Jill Daniels face actually keeps me up at night. Her wrinkles are the talk of the town. I don’t understand how someone in their 40s looks like that. Let JD serve as a harsh lesson for all women… take care of your skin 📢

  9. Stop with the hyperbole. On one side of the mouth only two inches of snow fell by the time they found the body at 6 am, on the other side of mouth it was a blizzard at midnight.

    “Allie was 17 years old and out driving past midnight during a blizzard. “

    If you have the facts, you don’t need to mislead.

      1. A blizzard has 35 mile per hour wind, snowfall reducing visibility under 1/4 mile, and sustaining those for at least three hours.

        How many declared blizzards had 2 inches of fallen snow in 6 hours??? ZERO you fucking retard.

        I doubt read hit him and more than likely he was was assaulted by people in the house, however I’m just pointing out that turtleboy minimizes the snowfall when talking about how much had fallen when CPD first investigated, and then exaggerates the snowfall when talking about people getting picked up or dropped off and even read driving in reverse when she allegedly hit him. Any open minded person would admit it casts a shadow over his “reporting”.

  10. Also underage drivers in Ma aren’t supposed to be driving after midnight and definitely not supposed to have any passengers until they’re 18…I’m assuming that just got swept under the rug though.

  11. Why is it taking so long to get all the evidence to the defense??
    Why didn’t they tape off the scene?
    Why didn’t these officers of the law come out of their home when John’s body was discovered?
    Where is the Cloe? Vet records?
    Can the house still be searched for clues, even tho there is new owner? Not sure, but I think blood stains will always remain…???
    TB thank you for what you are doing!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *